
What makes a peanut butter and jelly sandwich?
#1
Posted 19 August 2011 - 04:10 PM
How do you make your perfect peanut butter and jelly sandwich?
#2
Posted 19 August 2011 - 04:13 PM
- Peanut butter type: Slab of meat. Any will do.
- Jelly type: Bacon
- Bread type: Slices of cheese
Done.
#3
Posted 19 August 2011 - 04:26 PM

#4
Posted 19 August 2011 - 04:29 PM
I dare say I agree, heartily.Like this:
I love berries - blackberries, strawberries, blueberries, boysenberries, marionberries, salmonberries, huckleberries...
And then, sure- go for cashew butter, almond butter, mmmm. The bacon, though. No problem with that, definitely. That must be delicious.
#5
Posted 19 August 2011 - 04:31 PM
Edit: DP that looks like a Wawa sandwich stub! Do they have Wawa over in Indy? D:
Edited by Synile, 19 August 2011 - 04:32 PM.
#6
Posted 19 August 2011 - 05:11 PM
Seriously was my lunch for every day when I was 6.
By the end of the year my lunchbox smelled like rancid peanuts.

#7
Posted 19 August 2011 - 05:12 PM

Also, another good thing to try: nutella & banana sammich. <3
#8
Posted 19 August 2011 - 05:29 PM
Usually either Raspberry or Blackberry preserves
and a Honey Wheat bread.
mmmmmmm
from time to time my peanut butter gets replaced with Nutella, but I don't consider that a PB&J sandwich anymore.

#9
Posted 19 August 2011 - 05:45 PM
Strawberry Jam, no jelly here.
Potato bread - best GF bread everrrr.
#10
Posted 19 August 2011 - 06:54 PM
Due to over exposure as a child I have a hearty dislike of PB&J. :/
Edit: DP that looks like a Wawa sandwich stub! Do they have Wawa over in Indy? D:
Synile, it's from the Detroit Airport. If you'd just read the receipt.

And no, there are no Wawas, and no Sheetz. It's a pretty awful place.
Potato bread - best GF bread everrrr.
This, one thousand times this.
#11
Posted 19 August 2011 - 07:04 PM

#12
Posted 19 August 2011 - 07:25 PM
When we moved up to North Carolina from Georgia, we first discovered Sheetz. It's so new and wonderful to us. ;_; Nevermind this foreign, amazing idea of gas stations and mini marts that are CLEAN! And don't have tiles missing! Or only sell some suspicious bags of pork rinds and religious books/post cards! This is...I love it. <3Synile, it's from the Detroit Airport. If you'd just read the receipt. :PAnd no, there are no Wawas, and no Sheetz. It's a pretty awful place.Due to over exposure as a child I have a hearty dislike of PB&J. :/Edit: DP that looks like a Wawa sandwich stub! Do they have Wawa over in Indy? D:
This, one thousand times this.Potato bread - best GF bread everrrr.
Also, yes potato bread is good. :3 Sourdough's still my fave, though.
The layout...that looks like practically every receipt, ever. o__o
I was on my phone and only recognized the layout.
#13
Posted 19 August 2011 - 07:29 PM
#14
Posted 19 August 2011 - 07:41 PM
Just don't use


#15
Posted 19 August 2011 - 07:51 PM


#16
Posted 19 August 2011 - 08:53 PM
#17
Posted 19 August 2011 - 09:08 PM
#18
Posted 19 August 2011 - 10:32 PM
Crunchy peanut butter
Usually either Raspberry or Blackberry preserves
and a Honey Wheat bread.
mmmmmmm
from time to time my peanut butter gets replaced with Nutella, but I don't consider that a PB&J sandwich anymore.
Have you ever thought of doing the Nutella AND peanut butter?
o_o Do I have to go to Wawa, order a sandwich, and show you what I mean? I realize most of the poor, unfortunate world must do without Wawa. XD I feel so sorry for all of you who don't know what you're missing.
What's Wawa?
My PB&J
Wheat/anything BUT white bread
Creamy (and only creamy) peanut butter
Strawberry/anything but grape jam/jelly.
I used to hate jam/jelly, so I'm slowly re-introducing myself to it since my tastes have changed.
Sometimes I'll put honey instead of jelly/jam/preserves/whatever we have.
#19
Posted 19 August 2011 - 10:35 PM
That said, there is a method even here.
1. Start with TOASTED bread. Toasting sweetens the bread, reduces its ability to absorb water, increases it's ability to retain structure when wet...and it also makes the bread harder, so spreading things on the bread is made simpler.
2. In most sandwiches, the ingredients are water-based, so the bread could become waterlogged if it was in direct contact with the ingredients. This is why the original sandwich contained cheese (act as a physical barrier) and why most sandwiches contain mayo...which has oil in an emulsion and will keep the water from contacting the bread. With a PB&J, peanut butter WILL have oil in it and protect the bread on it's side from water...assuming you went creamy. But you've got nothing on the J side to protect the bread, seeing how it is in DIRECT CONTACT with a wet ingredient. This is why the J side of PB&J's always turns into mush.
Like I said, not my favorite sandwich.
Tricks like toasting and keeping the J side up at all times will help, but if you don't mind a little anarchy you can also cheat and butter the J side before adding the jelly.* Butter is 80% oil and its flavor jives with most jams, so bam. Protected AND flavor enhanced. Using a gelatin-based jam rather than a syrup preserve will also help (and you can tell which is which by spreading; syrups act like honey and stretch, while gelatin "crumbles."
*EDIT: The reason I say this will cause anarchy is because now the jelly won't stick...unless you do something funky like "butter a Z pattern and leave the rest untouched." Success of this trick depends ENTIRELY on what kind of jelly you're working with, but usually "cheated" J's will slide. When in doubt, only butter the center of the bread, where it will get soggy easiest and sliding is the least concern. The edge has the crust to protect it from getting waterlogged.
OK, on to the flavors:
Bread: toasted wheat
J: Any fruit. I'm partial to pear or blueberry, but blackberry's a solid backup which is always around.
PB: Personally, I prefer a smooth ALMOND butter. It's heavier than PB, and I've never seen it get to "creamy" but it has a kind of dark flavor that goes almost as well with wheat bread as it does with a celery stalk.
God. I've just realized I can geek out over the PB&J. What. The. FUCK.
Edited by Egann, 19 August 2011 - 10:47 PM.
#20
Posted 19 August 2011 - 10:42 PM
And the peanut butter must be creamy. Chunky PB just leaves bits of peanut stuck in my molars and then my cheeks get caught in between while I'm chewing.

#21
Posted 19 August 2011 - 11:15 PM
Words.
I didn't think I was a bully, but all I could think while reading this was how much I wanted to give you a wedgie.
#22
Posted 19 August 2011 - 11:19 PM

#23
Posted 19 August 2011 - 11:58 PM
Let me google that for you.
o_o Do I have to go to Wawa, order a sandwich, and show you what I mean? I realize most of the poor, unfortunate world must do without Wawa. XD I feel so sorry for all of you who don't know what you're missing.
What's Wawa?
To Egann- I was tempted to put toasted bread as an option, but I figured it wouldn't be that popular, and could easily just be explained for the few folks who might go for that. I prefer toasting bread for purely toast purposes (buttered and sometimes with honey), or for savory sandwiches (like a bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich with mayo, very similar to simple-but-delicious version at Waffle House).
#24
Posted 20 August 2011 - 12:05 AM
#25
Posted 20 August 2011 - 12:07 AM
-raspberry jam. Homemade is a plus, and a huge luxury based on location.
-Kraft smooth PB. Skippy can go to hell! Although, I've started buying into the 100% pure peanut butter for health reasons!
-Any bread on hand. But french toast it! Add some cinnamon!
-Sliced banana as well.
So good!
#26
Posted 20 August 2011 - 12:33 AM
Jelly would not be good in a sandwich :s.
#27
Posted 20 August 2011 - 01:12 AM
But I dont normally do just pb&j. I prefer peanut butter and honey mixed together with banana instead of jelly. but it has to be at least half honey if not more. And I don't do bananas unless they are in that sandwich. Lol. Sometimes I'm a very picky eater.
#28
Posted 20 August 2011 - 02:22 AM
Oh, you Canadians. Same as the Brits as far as names are concerned, I assume.Why do you guys use jelly? Or is that just your way of saying jam?
Jelly would not be good in a sandwich :s.
Alright, here's a chart to the American (USA) versions of fruit toppings and spreads!
Jelly is a clear, bright product. It is generally made by cooking fruit juice and sugar with pectin as a jelling agent and lemon juice as an acid to maintain a consistent texture. Jelly is firm and will hold its shape (it "shakes"). Generally, jelly contains no pieces of fruit, although specialty jellies, like pepper jelly, may include pieces of jalapeno or other pepper.
Jam is made from crushed or chopped fruit cooked with sugar, and often pectin and lemon juice. Jam can be a puree of fruit or have a soft pulp, but it does not contain chunks of fruit.
Preserves are fruit cooked with sugar to the point where large chunks of fruit or whole fruit, such as berries, are suspended in a syrup base. The texture of preserves is not smooth like jelly or jam.
Marmalade is a soft jelly, often citrus-based, that includes both the flesh and peel of the fruit suspended throughout the jelly base. The bitterness of the peel offsets the sweetness of the jelly.
Conserve is a mixture of more than one fruit, often with added nuts and raisins, that is cooked until it becomes thick. It is used as a spread for breads, pastries and meats, and in the latter use is closest to chutney.
Chutney is a spiced condiment of Indian origin (chatni is the Hindi word for strongly spiced) made of fruit or vegetables. It is typically served as an accompaniment to food, not as a spread. The spice level can range from mild to hot, and the consistency from a fine relish to a preserve or conserve. Fruit chutney consists of chopped fruit, vinegar, spices and sugar cooked into a chunky sweet-tart-spicy mix: according to one explanation, it blurs the Western distinction between preserves and pickles.
Fruit Butter, such as apple butter or prune butter, is fruit puree or pulp combined with sugar, lemon juice and spices, slowly cooked down to a smooth consistency. The "butter" refers to its spreadability: there is no actual butter in the product.
Fruit Curd is a creamy spread made with sugar, eggs and butter, generally flavored with citrus juice and zest.
So here we have jelly. You can see that because in the jar it's fairly gelatinous, it spreads thinly and has no solid fruit in it:

Versus jam, which is a bit thicker and smooth, often with fruit pulp, puree, and seeds - but like jelly, it usually has very little solid fruit matter in it:

Versus preserves, which are made with definable chunks of fruit:

#29
Posted 20 August 2011 - 09:15 AM
I put "other" all down the line because I think that as long as there is peanut butter, some kind of jelled fruit, and bread, it's a PB&J.
I never make them. Considering how much spread I slap onto toast in the morning, a PB&J would be a monster. But if I made one for myself, it would be smooth peanut butter (all natural, peanuts and salt only), jelly or jam from the Amanas (probably strawberry), and toasted potato bread (my "tasteless" bread of choice. If I want "good" bread, I'll bake it myself!).
I don't tend to like jam as much as jelly simply because the seeds get stuck in my teeth. And crunchy peanut butter is okay, but if I'm paying someone else to make it, it might as well be smooth!
#30
Posted 20 August 2011 - 11:20 AM

as for jelly and jam..I'm not to picky...I will have to say that I prefer black berry or black raspberry in whatever form.