We've been playing since Friday. At first, when we were in a 'hip' town and Pokemon were all over the place, it was really fun; and then I discovered that where we live, where it is perpetually 1998, the Pokemon seem to have never settled here in any numbers. At one point I had the game open and was actively playing it, looking at it and walking around the parking lot at my show, for ten whole minutes in which absolutely nothing happened, which to me is a nearly unforgivable sin for a game. I knew I could walk around my neighborhood and expect a similar result. It made me so mad I was going to delete it, but for some reason I put it off, then opened it instead later on, and lucked upon a few Pokemon I didn't have yet while I was walking around after the show having a chat with a friend. I was pretty excited to get them, which I didn't expect, so I decided to give it another try, or at least an experiment.
The experiment was to play it while I was shopping earlier today, and lo and behold the local Super Wal-Mart was as densely populated as our neighborhood was empty. And it made the shopping trip considerably more interesting and a little stranger. So I figured out a way I could enjoy it, and after a little more wandering around, at this point I like it enough that I looked up the answers to some of my questions about gameplay on the internet, and spent some of my free Google Play money on some more pokeballs and some lucky eggs.
This is the first Pokemon game I've ever played, and I've never played the card game or seen the anime. I know nothing of the lore, don't know who any of the characters are, and so far it's been pretty easy to get enough of the idea to just shrug and go with it. I played some Ingress for a while a couple years ago and this is basically a streamlined and rethemed version of that game, which replaces its convoluted mess of links and fields and portals with laser defense modules with simple one-stop gyms and pokestops, which makes it a less team-based experience but way better on the ground without all the tromping back and forth to build and maintain your links. And there are cute weird animal things you can stumble on in this kind of easter egg hunt with a lawn darts minigame. I wish I could choose to skip the animations if I wanted to: the capture animation has a few too many still beats, and the evolution animation is waaay too long for something you have to repeat every single time.
I'm on the same team as I was in Ingress, the blue team. I also noticed that this game deflects the 'turf war' aspects of the other a little by focusing on single gyms rather than large multipoint fields, and by having more than two factions. It should probably have more than three, so gang power is even harder to develop, but three is definitely an improvement.
I have a lot of problems with the app. It's clunkier than Ingress despite being several years newer, it crashes far too often and the moment it tends to crash is the single most infuriating moment it could possibly choose, the interface is unintuitive to me, there's no help guide, the pokemon look great but all the other art is not that great and some of the design work seems just plain unfinished. And my model of phone seems to break the AR mode AND the Pokedex, so I'm missing two entire features, one of which is one of the things people seem to be enjoying the most.
But except for the AR mode problem, which seems to be because my phone doesn't have a gyroscope, I'm pretty confident a lot of that stuff's going to get patched before terribly long, and if it stays popular I would expect a game like this to change in very interesting ways along with new technology.
TL;DR: I have justifiable reasons to not like it but I like it anyway. GO BLUE